• About
  • Advertise
  • Newsletters
  • Contact Cars UK

Cars UK

Car News, Views and Reviews

Motoring Directory
  • Home
  • Car News
  • Motoring Directory
  • Reviews
  • Classic News
  • Electric Car News
  • Motoring Advice
    • Car Finance Advice
  • Photos
You are here: Home / Report: Electric cars will NEVER be a viable alternative

Report: Electric cars will NEVER be a viable alternative

June 17, 2010 By Cars UK

E&T Magazine

E&T Magazine report says Electric Cars will never be viable

E&T Magazine – the magazine of the Institution of Engineering and Technology – has produced a report saying electric cars will NEVER be a viable alternative.

Let’s clarify that headline very slightly. Electric cars will never be a viable alternative to conventional cars with an internal combustion engine. That is the finding of a report by E&T Magazine, the magazine of the Institution of Engineering and Technology. Which is exactly what we’ve been banging on about forever.

E&T Magazine’s investigation questions the viability of investing in EV batteries using Lithium-Ion, or any other current battery technology. They also question the sense and viability of developing a charging infrastructure for electric cars which will never be a viable mainstream alternative to the ICE (internal combustion engine), and suggest Governments should instead encourage the development of high-efficiency diesels. Did we write this report?

E&T took the example of a standard Ford Focus capable of travelling for 400 miles on a tank of fuel and easily maintaining the 70mph motorway speed limit. They conclude that for an electric car to achieve the same it would need a battery bank weighing 1.5 tons (which in size would be bigger than an entire conventional car) which would cost approximately £100,000. They also conclude that although battery costs may fall a little in the next decade, it will still not be viable for an acceptable size battery bank to deliver more than a 100 mile range, and possibly half that in winter.

E&T also make mention of our assertion that although electric cars are zero emission at point of use they are actually more polluting than high-efficiency diesels and petrols when you take in to account coal-fired electric generation.

E&T also confirm our big worry about battery life. We’ve pointed out that manufacturers claims on battery life are a nonsense. Anyone with a laptop will tell you that their battery is knackered in a year or two, and car batteries on EVs are just the same as your laptop battery. In fact some EVs actually use laptop batteries daisy-chained together.

In the real world – from a domestic socket – it is likely to take up to 12 hours to recharge a car’s batteries. And as time goes on that will get longer and longer as the batteries age. What about rapid charge, I hear the EV advocates cry? Well, rapid charge will work – for a year or two. But within a couple of years it will render your very expensive bank of batteries almost useless.

So, more proof – if proof were needed – that claims of a bright future for electric cars as a replacement for the ICE are garbage. There is a place for EVs – ask Gordon Murray about the T.27 – as small, light, short-range City cars. But as a viable alternative to a conventional car? Only in cuckoo land.

Stand by for more abuse from Cuckoo Land. And the Land of the Deluded.

Related:

Filed Under: Uncategorised Tagged With: Electric Cars, Range Anxiety

Cars UK Motoring Directory

Have your say - leave a commentCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search By Distance

Motoring Directory

  • Number1Plates | UK’s Most Trusted Number Plate Supplier

    Number1Plates | UK’s Most Trusted Number Plate Supplier

    As the leading company in the number-plate industry, Number1Plates are …Read More »
  • Tomsett Kent | Hybrid & Electric Car Specialists

    Tomsett Kent | Hybrid & Electric Car Specialists

    Tomsett Kent MOT Centre, near Sittingbourne, is 5 minutes from …Read More »
  • Vantage Leasing

    Vantage Leasing

    Vantage Leasing is recognised as one of the leading prestige …Read More »
Chelsea Cars

Latest Car News

  • Kia EV4 Fastback Saloon ARRIVES to take on the Tesla Model 3 and Polestar 2

    Kia EV4 Fastback Saloon ARRIVES to take on the Tesla Model 3 and Polestar 2

  • Volvo EX90 and ES90 issues see Volvo take a £900 MILLION hit

    Volvo EX90 and ES90 issues see Volvo take a £900 MILLION hit

  • New Electric Car Grant of up to £3,750 – but will it have ANY impact?

    New Electric Car Grant of up to £3,750 – but will it have ANY impact?

  • Electric Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake REVEALED with up to 471-mile range

    Electric Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake REVEALED with up to 471-mile range

  • Skoda Enyaq Cargo – it’s an electric Skoda VAN

    Skoda Enyaq Cargo – it’s an electric Skoda VAN

Coops

Motoring Directory

  • JBR Capital | Specialist Finance for Classic, Prestige and Supercars

    JBR Capital | Specialist Finance for Classic, Prestige and Supercars

    JBR Capital is the UK’s only independent finance lender dedicated …
  • Morris Road Garage

    Morris Road Garage

    Morris Road Garage is a Bosch registered garage providing high …
  • Mansory UK

    Mansory UK

    Mansory UK, based in Knightsbridge, London, is sole exclusive importer …
  • Home
  • Car News
  • Car Reviews
  • Car Photos
  • Car Video
  • Newsletters
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Motoring Listings
  • Car Air Conditioning
  • Alloy wheel Specialists
  • Car Body Repairs
  • Car Finance
  • Car Insurance
  • Car Performance Specialists
  • Car Shipping Specialists
  • Car Storage
  • Car Styling
  • Car Transport
  • Classic Car Specialists
  • Motoring Offence Solicitors
  • Car Service Specialists
  • Audi Specialists
  • BMW Specialists
  • Jaguar Specialists
  • Land Rover Specialists
  • Mercedes Specialists
  • MINI Specialists
  • Porsche Specialists
  • Volkswagen Specialists
  • Bosch Car Service

Follow

Copyright © 2008-2023 · All Rights Reserved · Cars UK Privacy and Cookies Policy

Copyright © 2008-2021 · All Rights Reserved · Cars UK Privacy and Cookies Policy

Change Location
Find awesome listings near you!
 

Loading Comments...